Jan 18, 2013

Should Your Next Roof Be Asphalt or Metal?

Your roof is arguably the most important surface of your home because it is the most exposed area and comes under assault from rain, snow, wind and the sun.  That being said, many homeowners do not think about their roof until there is a leak already happening, a large blizzard coming on the radar or a recent hail storm that has moved through your neighborhood.

Many homeowners would say that price and good looks are the two most important things when it comes to the materials used on their roof, but don’t discount the longevity as well. We are going to discuss the pros and cons of asphalt versus metal roofing so you are able to make an educated decision that fits your lifestyle for your next roofing project.

Asphalt Shingle Roofing

For roughly the past 100 years, asphalt shingles have been the preferred roofing material in North America.  The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association states that 4 out of 5 homes are roofed with asphalt shingles today and 12.5 billion square feet of asphalt shingles are manufactured every year.

Home with an asphalt shingle roof


  • Proven reputation over the last 100 year of residential roofing
  • Economically priced compared to other roofing materials
  • Ease of installation, repairs & low maintenance
  • Many different styles from cost-conscious to designer to choose from
  • Great warranties ranging up to 50 years
  • Manufactured to resist external fire and flammability as well as wind resistance


  • Sometimes the colors and styles that tend to be selected can be dull and repetitive
  • Asphalt shingles do not hold up well to hail and can be vulnerable to moss, mildew & algae
  • If you do not have a well-ventilated attic your roof can suffer and your warranty could be at risk
  • Asphalt shingles are not properly recycled sometimes resulting in 8% of total builder waste per the EPA

Learn About the Components that Comprise GAF’s 50 Year Roofing System:

Metal Roofing

Metal roofing is dated back in use as far as 970 B.C. when copper was used. Metal roofs are made of 60%-65% recycled materials according to the Energy Commission. Unlike its asphalt counterpart, metal roofing is 100% recyclable when being removed making it the greenest roofing material on the market. Choosing to install a metal roof can save a homeowner up to 40% annually in energy costs.

Metal roof on a home in winter


  • Lightest roofing material to install on your roof
  • A roofing material that will last a lifetime
  • Highest roofing material warranty in the business
  • Amazing extreme weather performance  from leaks, wind and fire resistance
  • Environmentally friendly due to its high recycled content
  • It will not rot, crack, warp, curl, split, flake, peel, burn or break like its asphalt counterpart.
  • Insurance companies tend to give discounts due to their fire and hail resistance


  • Biggest drawback is the cost compared to asphalt roofing
  • Can have a harsh look in a residential area because of its history being used on agricultural buildings
  • They will expand and contract more than an asphalt roof
  • Has the possibility of rusting in certain climates with salt spray, extreme heat and heavy precipitation
  • Some builders will use low-grade metal

Learn More About Residential Metal Roofing: 

Browse Our Minnesota Roofing Projects:

Metal Roofing Reviews:

"My experience with Lindus was a 5 star experience!  Right from the beginning ALL those talked to were knowledgeable, courteous and took the time to answer all questions.  I have recommended your company to several of my neighbors, of which a couple have already had worked performed and others I believe will be contacting you soon.  I thank you for your commitment to quality and customer satisfaction!"

Jim J.
Hayward, WI
July 24, 2023

"Everybody has been very kind and courteous and I would recommend Lindus."

Nancy M.
New RIchmond, WI
July 2, 2022

"It was great!  I look forward to seeing it work."

Pat T.
St. Anthony, MN
February 17, 2023

"The roof is spectacular! My husband is very happy with it. Perfect color and it will be much better with the trees back there. Thank you so much."

Shaloe N.
Oakdale, MN
February 7, 2022

"Excellent communication throughout! Great crew and quality of work. It was clear they had our best interests in mind, finished on time and under budget! Would definitely use them again."

Laura U.
Hudson, WI
March 19, 2021

"Our house had a split re-roof, part metal and part asphalt and a partial roof extension. Given the fall timing and asphalt (no winter application) and then COVID-19, construction/roofing was not able to start until June. Roofing done in two days and gutters in day and a half. All in all, everything went rather smoothly and results for this old house were exceptional. I would recommend Lindus Construction for all of the above applications - Thanks for a great job!"

Marcus H.
White Bear Lake, MN
July 10, 2020
Contact Us To Schedule A Complimentary Estimate. Receive A Heat Map Analysis With Insulation Estimates Through April 30th.
Some restrictions may apply. Call for details.